The Value Of Nostalgia

crispydocUncategorized 4 Comments

In medicine, the suffix -algia indicates pain. Neuralgia is nerve pain. Myalgias are muscle aches of the type that we commonly feel during an acute viral illness (it is one of the common symptoms of COVID 19).

Nostalgia combines the Greek nostos, to return home, with -algia, pain.

We regard others who dwell in nostalgia as prone to melancholy, pining for a past they cannot return to. Yet many of us have indulged in the practice of nostalgia since the advent of the pandemic, recalling those freedoms of movement and social interaction we took for granted in past seasons.

A poet I've known since childhood sent me a link to a 5 minute podcast exploration of nostalgia, a reflective essay, and it got me thinking of a few moments where happy memories mingle with a sense of loss and what it means to inhabit those spaces.

Someone I love is sick, and the available data seem to indicate this is a condition that will not get better. This is heartbreaking, and at times we've discussed what it means through tears, or feeling disheartened through the lens of the experience we had when others had similar symptoms that deteriorated.

At the best moments, however, we've looked back on shared travels we've taken, aggravations we endured, even misunderstanding and hurt feelings that required tending to repair - and all of it imbues the current moment with more meaning and affection rather than less.

It enriches our present to recall the past that has laid the foundation for our relationship.

In the past week, we had an unexpected power outage. It left our kids needing to borrow my more fully charged computer in order to continue online distance learning using the wifi hotspot on my phone, meaning I had the better part of a day to function with no electrical gadgets at my disposal.

I found myself looking through my high school yearbook from senior year (it's the only one I have, since we lost our house in a fire the summer after my junior year), recalling the intense feelings and deep friendships (a few continue to this day) that marked that stage of life.

After our power was restored, I've enjoyed sifting through memories enough that our family sat down one night to look through online photo albums of prior summer travel. Not surprisingly, we all had strong recollections of the meals we shared.

A Mexican national in Chiapas wore his heart on his sleeve. He had met had married (and later divorced) an Israeli woman, and the result of his heartbreak was aromatic homemade pita bread and falafel garnished with pickled jalapeƱo vegetables. My wife and kids recalled that he took forever to grill each order fresh, and it was absolutely worth the wait.

Another favorite was a roadside grill the size of a large walk-in closet. The place sold souvlaki on the one main road that ran north to south along the length of a small Greek isle not mentioned in the guidebooks and avoided by the cruise ships.

We stumbled across it when the scent that wafted into our rental car compelled us to pull over to the side of the road and track it down. The memory of the soft Greek pita and perfectly spiced meat remains the quickest way to engage my son in a happy memory to this day.

Did those reminiscences underscore our sense of loss at missing out on our original summer plans? Absolutely, and that made us a little sad.

But mostly it helped us appreciate how fortunate we've been to have shared those experiences; to weather the COVID storm in health and security when so many others have struggled; and to have each other for support.

This past weekend, a record-setting heat wave beset the LA area, with some regions in the San Fernando Valley reaching 121 degrees. It was touching to see how our kids responded. My son moved a mattress on the floor of his sister's room, and they doubled up on cooling fans and had an impromptu sleepover to cope with the extreme heat, distracting one another until they fell asleep.

I miss the way we were.

But recalling it makes me more grateful for the way we are.

Comments 4

  1. 2020 certainly has given us a lot of opportunities to reminisce about what once was. I hope this is just a pause button year and we can resume making more memories soon.

  2. I love all your posts, but this one in particular really speaks to me.

    I do reminisce the past and feel nostalgia for what it was once. And it does bring me gratitude too. I’ve been fortunate and grateful to have experienced what life was like before and now we have to pave a way forward to a future that may look quite different.

    1. Post
      Author
  3. Interesting. None of us experienced WW2 in Europe, yet we have an opinion. Why? We were trained to accept a certain constructed narrative, in effect brainwashed. Someone who was there has an actual memory from an actual experience. Which entity, narrative or memory, has more value? Neither a memory nor a narrative has the force of reality. Which entity represents the nostos and why is it painful?

    Let’s say you had a love affair in your 20’s that was intense but didn’t work out because of incompatibility, but then in your 30’s you met the woman you have spent 20 years and had 2 children with. Why nostalgia for the now 30 year old age 20 relationship? The now 50+ year old woman you knew at age 20+ will certainly be nothing like she was at 20 and neither are you. I think nostalgia therefore is based in fantasy play, like lake Woebegone “where all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average.” That being said I think the future will bear little resemblance to the past. The propaganda we use and are given to define our “realities” become more fantastic and divergent from the truth by the day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.